Why is “I before E except after C” incorrect?

Daily edition

Why is "I before E except after C" incorrect?

The saying "I before E except after C" is a popular spelling rule, but does it have too many exceptions to really help?

T he Jackson 5 had an undeniable influence on pop culture, but while audiences were swooning, they were also learning classroom fundamentals with the hit song "ABC." We hear one of the most famous mnemonic devices in English in the song's opening lines: You went to school to learn, girl / Things you never knew before / Like "I" before "E" except after "C" / And why two plus two makes four… This elementary edict of "I" before "E" except after "C" sticks in our collective memory, thanks in part to one of the most popular songs of the 1970s, but it doesn't always hold true.

There is no blanket English grammar rule — everything has exceptions, and this spelling rule is no different. The rule best applies to French-derived words with the /ē/ sound, such as "grief" and "relief." This fulfills the first half of the guideline, and then words such as "receive," "deceit," and "receipt" fulfill the second half — "except after 'C.'"

Here's where things get iffy. There are many words that put "E" before "I" without a "C." Some of these words, such as "eight," "weigh," and "sleigh," have Old English origins. However, it's often impossible to guess a word's origin on sight, so this isn't a reliable method for spelling rules. An extended version of the jingle attempts to account for this spelling: "I" before "E" except after "C" or when sounding like "A" as in "neighbor" and "weigh." Surely this improved version is a guaranteed path to flawless spelling, right? Not quite.

Don't forget about words such as "weird," "glacier," "fancier," "seizure," "science," and "ancient." It turns out "ei" and "ie" make a lot of different sounds when paired together. Instead of memorizing a pithy rhyme with lots of exceptions, it can be more helpful to understand how pronunciation affects spelling. In English, the combination "ei" can make the sounds /ā/ (as in "vein"), /ē/ (as in "protein"), and /ī/ (as in "Fahrenheit"). When the letters "ie" follow a "c," they can be split into two syllables, as in "sci-ence," or the "cie" can make a "shh" sound, such as "ancient" or "efficient."However, even pronunciation rules have caveats, and teaching grade school kids this method can be confusing. The mnemonic device is a logical development.

As it turns out, implementing "I" before "E" except after "C" is not "as easy as 1, 2, 3." It can be a useful tool for spelling basic English words, such as the phrase "a piece of cake," but the full rule (along with its pitfalls) is much more complicated.