In colonial America, lobster was an undesirable food fed to prisoners.

U.S. History

L obster has long been considered a culinary delicacy, but in colonial America it was seen as the cockroach of the sea. When European settlers arrived in North America in the 17th century, New England's shoreline was littered with the clawed crustaceans. In fact, lobsters were so prevalent, they were used by Indigenous inhabitants as fishing bait or fertilizer. To the colonists, they served as a simple and abundant source of protein. Though eating lobster was useful in times of food scarcity — such as in 1623, when Plymouth Colony Governor William Bradford lamented that the settlers' best meal was a lobster or a piece of fish — it wasn't exactly desirable. The seafood was mostly fed to those with little say in their diets, such as prisoners housed near the coast and indentured servants working off their contracts.

Some stories about lobster's pauper past — such as that prisoners were punished by being fed lobster every day — have most likely been exaggerated over time. Rules were reportedly put in place to prevent inmates from receiving regular servings, while servants were said to write lobster limits into their contracts. But it's certainly true that for nearly two centuries, lobster was anything but a luxury. Its reputation didn't really begin to change until the 19th century, when improved transportation allowed fresh lobster to reach inland diners — many of whom, by the late 1800s, enjoyed vacationing in New England and saw the seafood as a rare treat. As demand grew, so did prices, and with better cooking techniques in the 20th century, lobster transformed from a lowly sea pest to a food fit for a king.

Together with

Tackle Your Credit Card Debt With 0% Interest Until Nearly 2027

Pay no interest until nearly 2027 with some of the best handpicked credit cards this year, all with no annual fee. They are perfect for anyone looking to pay down their debt, and not add to it! Click here to see what all of the hype is about.

Learn More

Thank you for supporting our sponsors! They help us keep History Facts free.

By the Numbers

Weight (in pounds) of the largest lobster ever caught

44+

Year the first cookbook by an American was published in the U.S.

1796

Did you know?

People once rented pineapples for their homes.

In Europe between the 16th and 19th centuries, the pineapple wasn't just a fruit — it was a symbol of status and wealth. The tropical fruit was laboriously imported from the Caribbean, meaning pineapples were not only rare but also came with a price equivalent to thousands of dollars today. Naturally, many people couldn't afford to buy one outright — but they could rent one. Pineapple-rental shops were common throughout the era, enabling people outside the upper class to possess one for a short period of time. The fruit was most commonly used as a centerpiece on dinner tables but was also carried around as a coveted accessory; often, the same fruit was used several times until it began to rot. The trend eventually faded as pineapples became more widely available in the 19th century, but for a time, simply having one on display was enough to impress.